Fast and Fair Blind Peer-Reviewed with Hybrid Access Scholar & Practical Journals

# # #

Financial industry at the crossroads between current practices and ethical virtues

Vol:0, №:0, Year:0

A COMPREHENSIVE ETHICAL RATING MODEL FOR MUTUAL FUNDS’ EVALUATION

Federica Ielasi
Department of Economics and Management - University of Florence
Italy

Sara Limberti
Department of Economics and Management - University of Florence
Italy

Abstract
In this paper, we elaborated and presented operational measures for calculating ethical rating in socially responsible investments. Starting from previous literature, we built an entirely innovative model, composed of four macro-classes and 74 indicators, including all the most important types of ethical criteria. The aim is to propose an intuitive instrument that allows institutional or retail investors to choose the most socially responsible investment that is in consonance with their request in terms of ethical issues. Our research collects 57 funds exchanged in the Italian market, and we calculated the ethical rating for each fund. We conclude that equity funds reach the higher average rating level. Nevertheless, our findings indicate that bond debts and ethical funds have a higher result for the macro-criterion ‘screening’, positive and negative, than equity and balanced funds, implying that this kind of SRI applies a deeper screening procedure.

References

1.  Assogestioni 2007, Italian Guidelines for Asset Management, Milan: Assogestioni

2.  Avanzi SRI Research 2002, “European SRI funds’ performance”, The SRI Funds Features, Issue 2, December

3.  Avanzi SRI Research 2012,Green Social and Ethical Fund in Europe, Milan: Vigeo

4.  Basso A., Funari S. 2002, “I Fondi Comuni di Investimento Etici in Italia e la Valutazione della Performance”, Il Risparmio, vol. 10

5.  Eurosif 2003, Socially Responsible Investment among European Institutional Investors, Report, Brussels: Eurosif

6.  Eurosif 2012, High Net Worth and Individual Sustainable Investment, Report, Brussels: Eurosif

7.  Eurosif 2014, European SRI Study, Report, Brussels: Eurosif

8.  Funari S. 2011, I “Vincitori in Etica”: Valutazione Multicriteriale di Fondi Socialmente Responsabili, working paper, Department Of Management, Venice: University Ca’ Foscari

9.  Gillan L. S., and Starks L. T. 2000, “Corporate Governance Proposals and Shareholder Activism: the Role of Institutional Investors”, Journal of Financial Economics, Vol. 52, no. 2

10.  Gillan S. L, and Starks L. T. 2007, The Evolution of Shareholder Activism in the United States, Journal of Applied Corporate Finance, Vol. 19, no. 1

11.  Girard C. 2009, Comparative Study of Successful France and Anglo-Saxon Shareholder Activism, working paper, Audiencia: Nantes School of Management

12.  Hamilton S., and Jo H., Statman M. 1993, “Doing Well While Doing Good? The Investment Performance of Socially Responsible Mutual Funds”, Financial Analysts Journal, Vol. 49, no. 6, Nov-Dec.

13.  Intonti M., Iannuzzi A. 2010, “Grado di Eticità e Pricing dei Fondi Comuni di Investimento Etici in Italia”, Bancaria, n. 4

14.  Kurtz, L., Lydenberg S. and Kinder P.D. 1992, “The Domini Social Index: A New Benchmark for Social Investors” in P. Kinder, S. Lydenberg and A. Domini (eds.), Social Investment Almanac, New York: Henry Holt & Company

15.  Markowitz H. 1991, Portfolio Selection: Efficient Diversification of Investment, Oxford: Basil Blackwell

16.  Marrewijk, M. V. 2003, “Concept and Definition of CSR and Corporate Sustainability Between Agency and Communion”, Journal of Business Ethics, 45 (1-2)

17.  Regalli M., Soana M., Tagliavini G. 2005, “I Fondi Etici: Caratteristiche, Spazi di Mercato, Ritorni Finanziari”, in Signori S., Fusconi G., Dorigatti M. (eds.), Etica e Finanza, Milan: FrancoAngeli

18.  Signori S. 2006, Gli Investitori Etici: Implicazioni Aziendali: Problemi e Prospettive, Rimini: Giuffré Editore



Key words
Social Responsible investments, Mutual funds, Ethical finance, Ethical rating

Citation
Ielasi F., Limberti S. 2015, “A comprehensive ethical rating model for mutual funds' evaluation” in Boitan I., Barbu T. (Eds.) Financial industry at the crossroads between current practices and ethical virtues (Studies in Philosophy, Law and Economics), Sumy: Taadler Publishing House, LTD, pp. 70-92. Available at http://taadler.com/a64

Preview or read without downloading